Showing posts with label deputy d.a. chamberlin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label deputy d.a. chamberlin. Show all posts

Thursday, July 4, 2013

Deputy D.A. Alvin


Happy 4th of July, to all fellow American readers!

I have finally got hold of the first half of season 9! It should arrive at the end of the week, and I will happily start viewing the episodes I have never seen uncut. Comparison posts will definitely follow.

A friend of mine has recently developed an interest in character actor Kenneth Tobey. This in turn has caused me to sit up and pay attention to something I was vaguely aware of but didn’t really stop to think about before.

Kenneth appeared in three Perry episodes, always as the same fellow. And that fellow is Deputy D.A. Alvin! Say Hello to another deputy D.A. who was around for more than one episode.

Here’s where things get even more interesting. Alvin is the first deputy we meet in season 4. He appears twice, in The Ill-Fated Faker and The Clumsy Clown. Then he vanishes and we hear nothing more of him, just as is the case with almost all of Hamilton’s season 4 assistants.

Only Alvin resurfaces, very briefly, in season 6’s The Weary Watchdog. As far as I know, he is the only deputy D.A. to appear in more than one season.

As the very first of Hamilton’s season 4 deputies, Alvin bears some similarities with Hamilton. His approach in court seems to generally be very professional, yet personable and kind. He treats the witnesses with dignity and respect, and tries to be gentle when they warrant it.

Then on the other hand, he has some very Hamilton-ish outbursts and defensive comments when he doesn’t like what Perry is up to and when he is trying to defend something he’s done that Perry doesn’t like. Of course, all of the deputies have dialogue written for Hamilton, but even in the way Alvin speaks in these intense scenes is quite a bit like Hamilton. Kenneth does, however, try to add his own touches whenever possible, such as in some of the gestures he makes when emphasizing a point. I do not recall Hamilton ever slamming his fist into his palm, as Alvin does at one point in The Clumsy Clown with gusto.

Alvin also looks a bit like Hamilton, with the same basic face shape and, especially in his first appearance, curly/wavy hair. Considering that he was the first of the season 4 deputies, I’m wondering if the casting director was deliberately looking for someone who resembled William Talman, in case he would still end up replaced.

I find it particularly fascinating that they brought him back two seasons later for The Weary Watchdog. His part is extremely minor, as he prosecutes C.C. Chang for grand theft, and pretty much the extent of his scene is strenuously objecting to Perry appearing as a friend of the court and having witnesses brought in before the judge rules on Perry’s motion.

Why didn’t they just bring in some random guy to play some random prosecutor, to be seen once and never again? Why did they choose instead to revisit the Alvin character, especially so briefly? Was it that Kenneth Tobey was available and someone thought “Hey, let’s use him again; he’s great”? Was it that someone liked the idea of showing one of Hamilton’s old deputies again, as a bit of continuity? Was it both of the above and more? Something else?

In any case, I’m always excited when an old television show has continuity. And it’s nice to see that a deputy with whom we are already familiar is still around two seasons later, still doing what he can to help Hamilton in the cause of justice. I can’t deny that it makes me long all the more that we had seen Sampson other times, but I’m happy to see another of the deputies too.

It’s a bit hard for me to decide what I think of Alvin as a character, since he is so much like Hamilton. I love Hamilton, but for me there's only one Hamilton and I like the deputies to be different. Kenneth does a very good job with the material he’s given, but especially in things such as The Weary Watchdog’s brief scene, Alvin seems more like an echo of Hamilton rather than his own person.

A lot of it has to do with approach. With each of the recurring deputies, the actor has his own interpretation of the similar lines and actions and brings them to life accordingly. We have Chamberlin’s businesslike, detached attitude. Bill Vincent’s overconfidence and blundering. Sampson’s absolute passion. Alvin’s professionalism.

After examining Alvin’s scenes more closely, I feel that he is the deputy probably most like Hamilton, followed by Chamberlin. Even with their different approaches, some lines and aspects of their characters remain very much like Hamilton, including Alvin’s kindness to the witnesses, his outbursts, and Chamberlin’s stubbornness that parallels Hamilton’s season 1 attitudes.

Sampson will probably always be my favorite. His supercharged approach intrigues me, particularly how he comes across as overconfident yet mature, completely unlike Bill Vincent. Sampson has experience that Bill lacks. It seems like every time we see Bill, he’s bumbling his way through a court case, except for when he questioned Hamilton on the witness stand in The Golfer’s Gambit. Other times, he’s stopped by Hamilton or chewed out by the judge.

By contrast, Sampson takes control. He builds some of the best cases the prosecution has ever been allowed to build throughout the series. He’s young and blunt and sometimes blurts things he probably shouldn’t, but overall he knows better what he’s doing than Bill does.

Now that I have fully noticed Alvin as the recurring character he is, I will likely want to introduce him into my stories somewhere along the way and flesh out his character. I’m still having a bit of trouble getting a handle on Chamberlin, so trying to take control with Alvin should be an interesting challenge.

Friday, April 26, 2013

Chamberlin


I did eventually finish and post that piece about Tobin Wade and company: http://31-days.livejournal.com/2976050.html
And this is the first part of it, from some time ago: http://31-days.livejournal.com/2921402.html

I always worry a bit when writing such pieces that the one hurt by the other will come off stubborn and for it to look terrible if they can’t readily forgive. But Aaron Stuart has every right to be struggling with it, after what was done to him and Marian. I still wanted a hopeful resolution, though.

I love how the episode shows what a great person he is in contrast with Tobin. The thought that he killed Tobin, even accidentally, is so sickening to him that he feels he can scarcely even begin to atone for it. Aaron is not a person who would deliberately harm anyone out of spite, no matter what was done to him first.

(And I find it amusing and interesting that Milton Selzer and H.M. Wynant appeared together in several other assorted episodes of shows. But they don’t share any scenes except in the Hawaii 5-O episode While You’re At It, Bring in the Moon. That’s a fun one.)

This past evening, faced with the choice of two episodes that don’t have Hamilton, on my local station and on Me, I finally chose my local station’s. It’s the last of the Chamberlin episodes, The Wintry Wife, so I decided to watch it and see if I could glean any inspiration for Chamberlin’s future role in The Malevolent Mugging, since he’s a supporting character in it.

I have the feeling that episode is one of the ones most heavily butchered. There were so many places where a scene and its music stopped abruptly, indicating a cut. I wonder if Chamberlin features into any of the clipped scenes.

Since that is the episode where we see him a lot outside of court, I paid special attention to how he was written and portrayed. And I was a bit surprised to note that in his first scene, when he talks to Perry in his office, he sounds a lot like Hamilton in season 1. He’s very formal with Perry (which is to be expected) and very stubborn about the case he’s setting up. Not that Hamilton isn’t always firm about his cases when he believes there’s enough evidence to substantiate them, but the actual stubbornness did lessen as time went on and he grew more willing to listen to Perry’s thoughts.

In court, Chamberlin is very businesslike in his approach, almost making him seem a bit detached from the situation. He definitely doesn’t have Sampson’s passion, and his approach doesn’t seem like Hamilton’s, either. So it’s nice to see that Robert Karnes did try to give him his own style.

Somehow now I imagine Chamberlin and Andy getting along particularly well, since Andy uses a businesslike approach himself.

I’m wondering if the way Chamberlin is written in his first scene has anything to do with the episode’s writer. It was Samuel Newman’s third Perry script. Perhaps the main episodes he was familiar with when he set about writing were from season 1. Those early episodes certainly are popular with fans. It’s not hard to believe that perhaps even while the series was originally running, those episodes could have been used as a guidepost for how to write the scripts.

Looking up his earlier Perry scripts, I’m intrigued to note that he wrote The Deadly Double, the infamous split-personality episode. Although dated now, and not an episode I often seek out, I’m still very impressed by Constance Ford’s performance as both girls.

The other script he wrote prior to this one is The Resolute Reformer, the season 4 episode featuring John Hoyt. And since it is one of the ones without Hamilton as well, that does mean that Samuel Newman’s only previous experience writing Hamilton came from season 1. It’s interesting that he went from that to being one of the champions of writing for the district attorney’s office, even penning The Fatal Fetish in season 8.

Out of curiosity now, I’m probably going to dig out my uncut copy of The Deadly Double and see how he wrote for Hamilton in that first attempt. There definitely were times in season 1 when Hamilton had awesome scenes, and it would be nice if Samuel Newman wrote a couple of them.

Thursday, November 8, 2012

Has the mysterious Leon been heard after all?


I am rather exasperated that I forgot to address one other intriguing element in The Daring Decoy. It’s just possible that Hamilton’s supposed secretary Leon was heard sometimes, after all.

An unidentified man talks to Hamilton on the intercom in Hamilton’s office, letting him know of an arrival to see him. Hamilton thanks him and says to send him in. Was he talking to Leon? Unless he has more than one male secretary, or had a male receptionist at one time, it’s likely.

This fellow had a very deep voice, which is a bit difficult to equate with the image of Leon I designed in my mind. Actually, I had a different image of Leon before I tried drawing him, and when I drew him, I ended up with someone a lot younger (and with wilder hair!) than my original envisioning. And now that that character is an established part of my stories, I’m a bit unsure of what to do about this deep-voiced person in canon who may be the real Leon.

I guess it’s certainly possible that even the version of Leon I ended up drawing could have a deep voice, going against type. But it’s certainly going to be hard to start hearing him with that voice in my mind, since I’ve been hearing him with a much different voice. I wish I’d remembered (or that someone else had remembered and told me) about that bit in The Daring Decoy before I designed Leon. And I’ll have to look through other early episodes to see if Hamilton speaks with this person at any other times. I’m very curious now!

I had thought I was drawing nigh to the conclusion of The Malevolent Mugging. It was scheduled to launch directly into a sequel, possibly called The Gruesome Graveyard. Hence, a lot of loose ends were to be left open as it closed. But upon reading and re-reading the proposed final chapter for The Malevolent Mugging, I just couldn’t feel good about closing the story there and marking it “Complete”, even though I would be immediately starting the sequel to continue things.

At this current time, I have determined that, like some novels, The Malevolent Mugging will be one big story comprised of two parts. The chapter I just put up today marks the end of Part One, and the next chapter should be the beginning of Part Two. Since I have publicly announced these intentions in the story itself, I hope I won’t end up changing my mind and reverting to the separate sequel idea again.

Part Two will continue the threads of plot that have been left open, including one of the important writer-created character’s disappearance and the continuing aftermath of Deputy Sampson being attacked. Various clues and plot threads will also entangle Daniel Conway and his nemesis Warner Griffith from The Daring Decoy, and the characters will discover that those people’s problems will have a direct bearing on the case at hand.

Instead of further confusion with Daniel and Sampson looking so much alike (considering that there’s already the Amory and Andy thing), I have half a mind to have either them or people around them think that they do not resemble each other that much, and be perplexed when anyone suggests it.

Also present will be a mysterious woman named Virginia, who claims to be a distant relation of the Petersons’ and demands inclusion among the recipients of a departed Peterson family member’s will. She quickly becomes a fixture around both Amory Fallon and Daniel Conway, seeming to be trying to stir up trouble for them both while coming across as completely innocent and oblivious. Amory suspects she is trying to drive him mad by making it look like they’re having an affair, while with Daniel she appears to be attempting to frame him for illegal activities.

I’ve been attempting to write for Deputy Chamberlin, furthering my idea of him and Sampson being friends. I’m finding, however, that Chamberlin is difficult to get a voice on. While it’s true that both he and Sampson canonically spouted dialogue written for Hamilton, Sampson delivered it with more flair and personality and it was fairly easy to find a unique voice for him. Chamberlin still doesn’t feel very developed, no matter how I try to work with his character in scenes. I’m hoping that as it goes on, I’ll be able to figure it out.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

The Case of the Nine Dolls

I stretched my artistic wings this week to once again attempt passable artwork of live-action people. Previously I failed in an attempt to draw Della and Hamilton together, but this time I managed to draw Amory Fallon and Lieutenant Drumm not too badly. At least, I found it good enough to finish the sketch and post it.


Most of my notations are below the picture, but one I’ll make here is hands. They are one of the most frustrating things to draw in any picture, no matter the art style. And yet it seems like I’m always drawing them. Occasionally I will hide them, as some other people do, but most of the time I seem to be a glutton for punishment.

And I discovered that I’ve been spelling Chamberlin’s name wrong. I kind of like it better with the second “A”, but since that’s incorrect I’ll be changing his tag and trying to spell it right in future usages both here and in my stories.

I got hold of The Case of the Nine Dolls and finally watched it again at long last. I remember how intrigued I was by it in the past, especially when Perry went to Switzerland! Scenes outside of California are rare, and usually it’s Paul featured in them when it happens. The scene at the toyshop is what I remembered most vividly, although I mistakenly got it in my head that it showed Perry walking down the street.

The plot involves one of Perry’s youngest clients ever, little Peggy Smith, who wants him to find out who she really is and who keeps sending her these dolls from Switzerland. He was planning to go on a fishing trip in Scotland, but he rearranges his plans after being touched by her sweetness and her plight.

While trying to unravel the confusion and the cover-ups, Perry stumbles into what is no doubt the most chilling scene in the entire series. I feel it’s only rivaled by Button’s endangerment in The Missing Button, and even then, I think this one is somehow much more eerie.

After investigating the toyshop where the dolls are purchased and sent to Peggy, and meeting several vacationing Americans who seem oddly interested in the matter, Perry returns to his hotel room and finds that someone has left a broken doll and a note. The note reads, “This can happen to little girls, too.”

I remember always being stunned by that scene. Threats against children are particularly horrifying and sickening, and it seems especially unusual to see one in such an old series.

Alarmed, Perry of course cancels his original ideas to go on to Scotland from Switzerland. He returns home, securing a seat on the same flight as the strange people from the toy store. He chats it up with one of them, Linda. She is aloof and professes no knowledge of any of what’s been happening.

Meanwhile, Paul has been digging and has found a possible connection to Peggy in the Jeffers family. I was rather amused to see that name pop up; Richard Anderson’s character on The Wild Wild West is named Jeffers, and I’m writing a story about him.

The Perry character is a gruff and grouchy old man, a wealthy oil baron. And it so happens that Linda and the others Perry met are related to him. Linda tells him about talking to Perry on the flight home and he is not pleased. When Perry shows up at the house wanting to talk to him, Linda leaves the room. Perry tries to explain about Peggy possibly being Jeffers’ granddaughter, but Jeffers is certain Perry is trying to perpetrate some fraud and orders him out.

When told about the encounter, Peggy is disappointed but accepts it bravely and says he’s probably not a nice man anyway. Perry tries to reassure her that Jeffers is likely very nice. Linda comes in then and asks Perry to stay away from Jeffers. Peggy is brought out of the library in an attempt to soften her heart, but Linda is very oddly repulsed and orders Peggy to keep away from her. She flees the office, leaving everyone stunned. Peggy finally, quietly asks to go back to the boarding school where she’s been living.

Gah, that poor girl. It’s heartbreaking, the way her family treats her. The little girl playing her does an incredible job. Peggy is so sweet and kind and polite. It’s hard to imagine anyone not wanting her.

It doesn’t take long for Jeffers to have a change of heart. He invites Perry back to the house and asks him to bring Peggy. They have a sweet meeting and Jeffers accepts Peggy as his granddaughter.

Things quickly go wrong again, however. Jeffers is killed and Linda is blamed. It comes out that Jeffers was going to change his will and leave everything to Peggy. Everyone in the previous will now has reason to have wanted him dead, but it was Linda whose name Jeffers called out right before he died. And it was Linda, it seems, who was seen running upstairs immediately afterwards.

At the jail before the hearing, Linda finally reveals to Perry why she can’t stand being around Peggy. It seems that Peggy is the daughter of Linda’s best friend and Linda’s fiancé, who ran off together and eloped. Every time Linda sees Peggy, she’s reminded of their betrayal. She hates herself for her feelings, and knows it isn’t Peggy’s fault, but she just can’t bear to so much as look at Peggy.

Chamberlin is the prosecutor for the case. As is usual with him, he handles it with dignity, grace, and maturity. While mostly serious, he does show a bit of a sense of humor, smiling in amusement when one of the witnesses says her husband told her they need a brandy because “it isn’t every day you lose nine million dollars.”

I wonder if this episode was filmed before Chamberlin’s other episodes. It’s harder to see that lighter piece of hair, which I had assumed was a piece that was turning gray. (Although in grayscale it’s hard to tell what the colors are supposed to be.)

The episode is very intense and unique and Peggy is adorable. But seriously, what a crew! I can’t help wondering what on earth happens to her after the episode’s end. It seems she’ll be able to live in the Jeffers mansion, or at least, that’s the implication. But who will be living there with her?

There’s the husband and wife who knew about Peggy’s existence before but were willing to cut her off completely so they could have the money (even though they were fairly well off already). That seems to have been the case with the husband and wife servants, too. And the wife (played by the wonderful Jeanette Nolen, here with a Scottish accent) is the murderer.

And then there’s Linda, who still seems unable to tolerate being around Peggy. At the episode’s end she’s determined to move out of the house. She’s finally won over enough by Peggy’s purity and innocence to bend down and embrace her, which is certainly a vast improvement. But was she won over enough to decide to stay with her? That’s left up to the imagination. The episode ends with the embrace.

When I was younger, I thought the embrace meant definitely that she was going to stay. Seeing it now, I’m just not sure. It’s really ambiguous.

I have to say, I really wish Jeffers hadn’t been killed. It was heartbreaking. He was so happy to finally realize he had a granddaughter, and he was the only one who really wanted Peggy, and then he was murdered. He definitely goes on the short list of good people who were killed off on the series.

Perry and Della both have some adorable interaction with Peggy. Near the beginning of the episode, Della assures Peggy that she’ll come see her at the boarding school. And throughout the episode, it’s Della who brings Peggy to Perry’s office and other locations. I like to think that Della kept up her friendship with Peggy following the episode’s end. I’m sure she would have.

Overall, I still love the episode. But I’m stalled from accepting it into my top tier of favorites due to wondering about Peggy’s fate post-episode and wishing Jeffers hadn’t been the murder victim.

Thursday, July 19, 2012

Various musings on Robert Karnes and H.M. Wynant

I’ve been taking my time getting today’s post done, as I’ve been trying to figure out exactly what I should be writing about! I have quite a few topics floating around in my mind, but some of them are being held up by various glitches and frustrations that are preventing me from learning a bit more about them first. (Such as, concerning the inability to execute one topic, what is wrong with Yahoo Groups the last couple of days?! I’m having a horrid time loading the site. Right now it refuses to cooperate. Yesterday it was extremely sluggish.)

With my interest sparking a bit more where both Sampson and Chamberlain are concerned, I’ve been peering at their actors’ profiles and looking for other things to watch them in. And then I’ve been running across them by accident, as well; both are quite prolific character actors. I found it hilarious when, a few hours after watching The Wintry Wife, I was watching Sea Hunt and suddenly realized, “Oh my gosh! That’s Chamberlain!”

Robert Karnes, I find, is quite easy to spot from that distinctive piece of lighter-colored hair standing out against his mostly dark hair. I’ve stumbled across him on more than one episode of Sea Hunt, and judging from his resume, he’s been in several old movies and guest-starred on several old television shows that I’ve been familiar with for years. He’s even been on The Andy Griffith Show.

It’s been the same story with H.M. Wynant. (And he’s also one of the few Perry actors playing a recurring character who is still alive today. And active. Awesome.) I knew someone seemed familiar in The Wild Wild West episode The Night of the Simian Terror. But until I saw the cast list it just didn’t click.

That’s usually the case when I’ve run across him in other Perry episodes. I recognize him, but can’t place where until I see the name. I’ll probably start finding it easier to spot him in the future, now that I’m actively looking.

He has quite an impressive roster of Perry episodes, I see. Like William Boyett, he appeared in every season except season 2. He was in all the other seasons once, save for season 4, of course, where he was around three times. His characters seem to vary in their involvement with the cases, and in whether they’re good or bad, if I remember right. I can’t recall if he was ever the murderer or the victim. (I don’t think so.)

Robert Karnes was only in one other episode of Perry besides the four in season 4. In season 1, he appeared in The Hesitant Hostess as a character called Detective Purvis, and I . . . can’t recall anything about him off-hand.

I do know Robert often played law enforcement types, even appearing as a co-star in the series The Lawless Years, which sounds like it might be a more historically accurate version of some of the events depicted in The Untouchables (more or less). It follows some police in New York during the Roaring Twenties. And they actually had the real, main NYPD detective depicted in the show as a technical consultant! I think I need to try that series.

I still have one Perry episode with Chamberlain to see. My local station skipped The Nine Dolls again, despite actually listing it on their schedule this time! Ridiculous! I was looking forward to seeing it again after all these years. I’ve sent for the disc from Netflix; I should have it next week unless I rearrange my queue again. There’s so many things I’m gathering up to see that my queue sees quite a bit of shifting around.

One oddball thing I’ve noticed about Sampson: his name is never spoken. You only know who the heck he is by looking at the cast list. He’s always called “Mr. Prosecutor.” Exactly why is this? I hope the explanation isn’t something silly, like the network being worried over the character having a Biblical name. I would kind of doubt that, judging by the various references to the Biblical Sampson on The Wild Wild West, which ran on the same network. (But if that was the problem, why didn’t they change the Perry character’s name to begin with?) I think Sampson is the only one of Hamilton’s assistants whose name has never been mentioned in the spoken dialogue at all.

I’ve been tinkering with having both Sampson and Chamberlain, very occasionally, in my stories ever since my first Perry mystery. Recently I wrote a random blurb on Livejournal that has them both and features a bit of interaction with Hamilton. I’m thinking they will most likely appear with greater prominence in a future mystery, perhaps the very next one, as I’m wrapping up The Denying Detective at long last.

It really was the writing challenges I took on for May and June that seriously slowed this story down; that’s obvious from how fast I’ve been putting out the chapters this month. I think the only thing left now is the epilogue, and making sure all the last loose ends are tied together. Then I’ll be starting on the next one, which I think I’ve been calling The Malevolent Mugging. While Andy and his double Amory Fallon will dominate the main plot, I may run a cocurrent subplot with Hamilton, Sampson, and Chamberlain.

Sampson and Chamberlain may have a scene or two to themselves to interact in; I’m kind of fascinated to see how they might communicate with each other. Chamberlain certainly seems to be more of a veteran prosecutor, while Sampson is a young and impulsive fellow. Save for that tired gag of Perry being wildly accused in The Waylaid Wolf, Chamberlain comes across as a mature and skilled person. And even the wild accusation is handled with dignity, really.

The Livejournal blurb I wrote, while featuring them both, didn’t really allow for any interaction between them. Sampson is badly hurt while protecting Hamilton from a sudden and shocking attack. Chamberlain tends to him while Hamilton tries to catch the assailant, but the focus is on Hamilton’s point-of-view, and when he gets back, his interaction with Sampson. I might write an experimental follow-up showing things from Chamberlain’s point-of-view and allowing for him to interact with Sampson.

One thing I quickly realized: If those deputies are going to appear in stories with any prominence, their first names will need to be in there. Chamberlain’s we already know from The Wintry Wife: Victor. But Sampson’s remains unknown. And I’ve been discovering that you can’t combine just any name with a name as cool as Sampson. It’s very difficult to find anything that fits. The only one I’ve matched up so far as a possibility is Gregory, which seems to carry enough power to sound good but doesn’t cancel out when combined with Sampson. And yet I’m not sure it fits the character well enough. Thoughts?

Sunday, July 8, 2012

Further pondering on Deputy D.A. Sampson

With my local station deeply involved in season 4, it gives me an interesting chance to review episodes I don’t normally watch if they’re not on television.

I was rather angry the last time they played these episodes, as their website had originally indicated they would be skipping them. And, just slipping back into the series and rediscovering my love of Hamilton, I did not want to see him vanish so soon. So when The Crying Cherub episode in season 3 started and I realized what they were doing, I was not pleased. I will freely admit I looked for faults in each and every assistant D.A., comparing them unfavorably to Hamilton and just wanting him back.

This time around, having expected the episodes, I’m much more relaxed. But that doesn’t mean I feel I was completely blind in my earlier analyses on the deputies. Most of them are still dull to me, or at least, lacking any unique personalities. With their dialogue having been written for Hamilton, but their actors of course being unable to deliver it the way William Talman could, court scenes with them never had that same spark.

Chamberlain and Sampson, as previously noted, seem to be the ones the writers lavished the most attention on. Not only do they show up multiple times, what they’re allowed to say and do in court is much greater than the other assistants’ screentime allotted. It’s a bit hard to put into words, but they not only are given more personality than the rest, they’re given more of Hamilton’s personality.

Chamberlain has more extensive interaction with the other characters and even Perry. In The Wintry Wife, as previously noted, he plays a very large part throughout the whole thing. (Oh, if only that had been Hamilton. Although I could do without him flinging another wild accusation at Perry during court, so perhaps I’m satisfied that it was someone else that time.

EDIT: Or wait a minute, was the accusation that time? I saw Chamberlain accuse Perry in The Waylaid Wolf, so either I mixed up two "W" episodes or else it happened in two different Chamberlain episodes. Which is, unfortunately, conceivable. Well, I'll know the answer soon.

I am so glad that episode marked about the last time that tactic was used until the series finale. And it really shouldn’t have been used again then, either, but I digress.)

Sampson is definitely stereotypical and blustery. His voice probably has a lot to do with his image. He speaks loudly and pompously a lot of the time, especially in his first two appearances. In The Envious Editor, not so much. Aside from an arrogant comment on thinking Perry should stipulate the defendant’s guilt in the murder (!), he mostly speaks in a normal tone of voice and doesn’t make any other cringe-worthy slip-ups that I can recall.

But I was remiss in saying he was never polite or kind. Much like Hamilton, he did indeed try to treat two witnesses better in particular. In The Loquacious Liar, he is quite compassionate towards the widow of the murder victim (played excellently by the talented radio, movie, and television actress Lurene Tuttle—who needs a spotlight post here for her and her many Perry characters). And in The Red Riding Boots, he actually tries to be gentle with the teenage witness. She does end up starting to cry from that examination, but that is not the point when she reaches the hysterical stage, as I was incorrectly remembering for some reason.

In general, I’m the sort of person who loves every character in a series. Or at least, I rarely hate anyone I don’t eventually warm up to. All characters have their places in the tale, heroes and villains alike. (I still find James Coburn’s character in The Envious Editor absolutely repulsive, however!)

Even before, I did carry a certain fondness and fascination for Sampson. I wouldn’t have analyzed him as being the most interesting of the assistants from season 4 if I hadn’t. Nor would I have arrived at the idea of him idolizing Hamilton.

I had already softened a great deal more towards him a few weeks ago, after noting some similarities between his courtroom style and that of Miles Edgeworth’s in the Phoenix Wright manga (Japanese comic) series. Off-hand, I can’t include the games in that statement too; it’s been so long since I’ve had much to do with those. But in any case, Miles is my favorite character from that franchise. I thought Miles was more like Sampson in the manga than in the games, but I could be wrong on that. Although in both the manga and the games, I do know that Miles had infinitely more development than Sampson was allowed.

I keep picturing Miles as being an assistant D.A. rather than an actual district attorney. Hence, with the American versions of Phoenix Wright taking place in Los Angeles, I got the image stuck in my head of Miles working in Hamilton’s office and him and Sampson sometimes meeting. (And probably clashing, oh dear. They’re too similar in arrogance and being headstrong to get along well, I would think.) Now I can’t unsee the idea, despite the fact that Phoenix Wright is supposed to take place several years into the future and uses a different court system, for video-gaming purposes. One of these days I expect I’ll be writing a short story on Sampson and Miles, just for my amusement. Poor Hamilton would probably have a headache with all the commotion.

(If I do write it, I would be most unlikely to incorporate either the new court system or the slightly futuristic date. It would be more like if the same characters had been born a few years earlier and were involved in present-day goings on, making them contemporary with my present-day Perry stories.)

I like Sampson even more now that I’ve had a chance to watch and ponder on his episodes again. H.M. Wynant did a wonderful job with the portrayal. Perhaps it was his idea to read the lines as he did, rather than the idea of the various directors’. I would be interested to know if that were so, considering how it made Sampson the most memorable of the assistant D.A. parade, and also how and why H.M. Wynant determined to tone the character down at various points.

I wish we could have seen Hamilton interact with him, at least once. But ah well, that is also a challenge for the fanfiction writers.

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Deputy D.A. Sampson: The Series' Stereotypical Prosecutor

He had instead conversed with a young deputy D.A.—Sampson, a blustering upstart. Sampson was about as different in personality from Mr. Burger as one could get. Nevertheless, he had a great deal of respect and admiration for the deceased prosecutor and was reeling over his murder. He had, in outrage, vowed to bring the killer to justice.

That was, at least, one thing upon which Tragg could agree with him.
—from The Persecuted Prosecutor, chapter four

In the books, Hamilton Burger is largely a stereotypical prosecutor: blustering, angry, and with a constant chip on his shoulder towards the defense attorney. In the TV series, this is thankfully not the case. While he is, of course, frustrated by many of Perry’s actions, he is able to look beyond that, respect Perry’s skills, and even cultivate a friendship with his in-court rival.

During William Talman’s suspension in the latter half of season 3 and throughout much of season 4, we were introduced to a steady stream of deputy district attorneys for Perry to match wits with. Most of them are unmemorable. They come, recite lines written for Hamilton Burger, and are defeated. The added spark between the characters is absent. There is no strong connection between Perry and any of them, as there is between him and Mr. Burger.

Most of them appear for one episode each and then vanish. At least two are around for repeat performances: Chamberlain (who receives quite a large share of the spotlight in one of his episodes, The Wintry Wife, and makes me long all the more for it to have been Mr. Burger in that episode) and Sampson. Chamberlain is in four episodes, while Sampson claims three.

Chamberlain has a bit more personality than most of the deputies, although offhand I don’t have a great deal to say about him. In The Wintry Wife more than any of his other ventures, it’s obvious that his lines and part were written for Mr. Burger. He even makes one of those wild accusations during court that the writers were so fond of falling back on. Everything is so much the same, and yet it isn’t at all, because it’s Chamberlain instead of Mr. Burger. And it really could have been any of the deputies. They are almost all so alike, even Chamberlain, that recalling which specific one is in a particular episode is difficult.

Sampson, on the other hand, is someone who just can’t be forgotten about. He is the most irritating of the deputy D.A.s, but he is also the most interesting and the most memorable.

Who knows why Sampson was written as he was. Maybe the writers were deliberately trying something new. Maybe they wanted to see how the viewers would accept a stereotypical prosecutor.

That is exactly what Sampson is. He blusters, he yells, and he badgers the witnesses. During his first episode I wanted to shake my fist at the screen and demand to have our Mr. Burger back. Mr. Burger may get frustrated at Perry, but he is a kind and compassionate person and tries to be polite with the witnesses.

Case in point number one: In The Loquacious Liar, Sampson’s approach to a hostile witness who refuses to simply answer Yes or No to questions is to continually interrupt, raising his voice louder and louder each time as he demands for the witness to say Yes or No.

Mr. Burger’s approach to the exact same problem, shown in multiple episodes, is to keep his voice normal and remain polite as he tries to get the witness to cooperate. He has to keep interrupting too, but it’s his attitude as he does it that’s key.

Case in point number two: Sampson continually badgers the poor, already shaken teenage witness in The Red Riding Boots, demanding answers of her until she’s reduced to tears. He sees no distinction between her and any other, older witness.

Mr. Burger’s approach to young and/or distraught witnesses, as shown in The Vagabond Vixen and other episodes, is to be gentle and thoughtful. He speaks kindly to the teenage vixen, not pressing her harshly as he has for some older, witnesses. For him, there is a difference. “Remember, Mr. Mason,” he implores before cross-examination, “she’s scarcely more than a child.”

It’s difficult to know what to say about Sampson’s personality aside from his appalling behavior in court. I tend to think of him, as evidenced by the fanfiction snippet at the beginning of this post, as being devoted to justice and perhaps idolizing the district attorney. I don’t know where I gleaned the latter concept, as it’s equally or more possible that he feels Mr. Burger is too kind and that one needs to be more aggressive to get the job done. Perhaps by having him look up to Mr. Burger instead, I’m trying to find some redeeming, endearing quality to his in-your-face personality.

In any case, perhaps the writers decided the stereotypical approach just wasn’t working. In his final episode, The Envious Editor, Sampson has toned down considerably. While there is a bit of that belligerent spark left, overall he fades more into the background, as by and large his comrades tend to do.

Nevertheless, his normally sharp, blustery behavior ensures that Sampson will always stand out among the deputies. And while I find him more interesting than the rest, I am relieved that he was only around for three episodes—and that Mr. Burger is not like him.